11 Comments
User's avatar
Maria's avatar

Congratulations! And I'm glad to hear that the retirees, coming from different perspectives, all agreed on Medicare. That's a good sign or least litmus test for general public opinion, I think.

Expand full comment
Anna Stern's avatar

This is an election year ploy.

“Mayor Eric Adams announced today that his administration is abandoning the Medicare Advantage push—AT LEAST FOR NOW. ..

“We’re not moving forward with [Medicare Advantage AT THIS TIME, however, we are still obviously very glad that the court made this decision because it's essentially saying that we still have the legal right to change or alter healthcare coverage as the city. They basically acknowledged we need to have flexibility to adapt our policies based on how things are changing, [and] market conditions.”

Considering that he said before he was elected the last time that he was opposed to Advantage, and then fought us endlessly, and now it’s pretty clear he’s gonna lose, why not make a promise? And he might’ve learned a trick from the Trump administration, that was going to drop charges against him – for now.

I hope I’m wrong, but let’s see what happens with the election. As I said, the massive revenue short fall and Federal cuts mean that budget is going to be brutal.

Expand full comment
Ilene Shifrin's avatar

It is not accurate to say that the City Council ultimately did not endorse the Mayor's plan to move retirees into a MAP. Almost from the beginning of this fight (almost four years ago), the Retiree Organization has tried to get legislation passed in the Council to preserve retirees' right to Traditional Medicare. The Council has failed to get such a law passed (a/k/a Intro 1096). The Mayor has said that he will not pursue the MAP plan "at this time." That's no guarantee. The only solution is to get the City Council to pass Intro 1096. Jemima

Expand full comment
Marianne Pizzitola's avatar

Thank you Wendell!! For your unwavering support!!

Expand full comment
K Vander Molen's avatar

When it was time to choose Medicare Advantage plan vs Medicare + Supplements, I learned that people who wrote the MA plans did NOT choose it for themselves, that’s all I needed to know about that choice! This needs to be more widely known.

Expand full comment
Susananda's avatar

Yes and you can count on true advice from your local council on aging.

Expand full comment
Sandra Greer's avatar

A great victory against the thieves who have been pushing Medicare Disadvantage! They ought to be ashamed. It really is a racket. I don't know how many CEOs of Med Insurance Rackets need to be killed to keep us save from marauders!

Expand full comment
Robert H Cowen's avatar

This is not a real victory, since a future Mayor could still remove our City paid for Medigap insurance, thus forcing many of us retirees into the current City's favorite Medicare Advantage plan.

The only solution is to pass Intro 1099 in the City Council, a bill that the current Speaker and candidate for Mayor, Adrienne Adams is adamantly opposed to.

Expand full comment
Randy Zmudka's avatar

This is a great victory for NYC retirees. AT&T took away Medicare subsidies and pushed the Medicare Advantage scam down the throats of their retirees a couple of years ago. Corporate greed at its finest.

Expand full comment
Allyster Waters's avatar

Wonderful news!!!! Congrats on the VICTORY!!!

Expand full comment
Susananda's avatar

Trust this great decision. Another reason to I Heart New York City

Expand full comment